Menu Close

Preserve This Early-Stage Bet That Benefits National Security

The battle in Ukraine is proving how essential innovation is to army success. As this battle unfolds, the world watches as small industrial drones play a useful position on the battlefield. Meanwhile, small-satellite firms pivoted seemingly in a single day to offer communications and intelligence infrastructure. Seemingly oblivious to this actuality, some members of Congress are calling for an finish to the Department of Defense’s longest operating and most profitable innovation program, whereas others have advocated for ending its first-stage innovation analysis grants.

The Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) program, energetic because the Nineteen Seventies, makes use of small phase-1 expertise discovery and bigger phase-2 prototyping efforts to guage, qualify, and show rising expertise for army functions. SBIR’s opponents argue alternatively that the quantity of proposals overwhelms reviewers, the contract worth is simply too small to be helpful, and a handful of firms gobble up the lion’s share of awards. Such arguments miss the mark as they fail to account for protection innovation’s foundational premises: entice most participation from expertise startups, check their worth in assembly authorities wants, and transfer solely a choose sub-group on to prototyping. The American innovation system will thrive when the SBIR program is structured to quickly check and validate the utmost variety of new applied sciences towards authorities wants.



The purpose of this text is to not ship a point-by-point critique, however to elucidate why SBIR phase-1 awards are an important step to maximizing the potential of dual-use expertise. Phase-1 awards are an accessible pathway for a expertise startup to find if they’ve actual potential to be a dual-use firm. They encourage and permit most participation from expertise startups, permitting the U.S. army to profit from the broadest doable vary of venture-capital-funded expertise. Phase-1 awards permit a performer to validate and flesh out their use-case in order that the ensuing phase-2 has technical feasibility to get into the palms of warfighters and impression the mission. It merely can’t be overstated that mission impression for warfighters is the one legitimate efficiency indicator for protection innovation, so it needs to be the first driver of the innovation pipeline.

When he chaired the Defense Innovation Board, former Google chief government officer and chairman Eric Schmidt famously quipped that the Department of Defense “does not have an innovation problem; it has an innovation adoption problem.” His remark echoed the now-famous passage from the 2018 National Defense Strategy titled “Deliver performance at the speed of relevance.”

Why am I speaking about startups? Because they’ve the expertise, the event budgets, and the drive to seek out product-market match and scale as quick because the market will permit. Defense Innovation Unit director Michael Brown has acknowledged that the U.S. army wants industrial expertise as a result of it isn’t growing what it wants organically. By tapping dual-use industrial expertise, the Department of Defense can entry higher options in essential areas equivalent to transportable energy, laptop imaginative and prescient, and autonomy whereas leveraging the size inherent with venture-funded industrial options. The Silicon Valley Defense Group’s Emerging Technology and Venture Capital Working Group information exhibits that enterprise capital funding in defense-relevant applied sciences has elevated 300 p.c between 2014 and 2018, whereas protection analysis and growth spending declined by practically the identical margin. Total enterprise capital investments have been rising on a breakout scale for the final decade.

I lately accomplished a thesis (publication pending) detailing the materiel innovation pipeline, an eight-step course of that an rising expertise startup with minimal or no expertise working with the Department of Defense might navigate to quickly area an answer that creates mission impression for warfighters. To perceive why phase-1 awards are vital, it’s essential to see the place they match within the full course of from an AFWERX “Ask Me Anything” occasion to a program of file.

The pipeline just isn’t full. In reality, the protection innovation ecosystem has been fairly profitable with the primary 5 steps however continues to battle with the final three. Progress over the past 5 years has been outstanding, together with demonstrating that open subject phase-1s carry new firms to the protection market, improve their possibilities for elevating enterprise capital, and improve their probability of successful a non-SBIR authorities contract. The introduction to a current analysis paper co-authored by AFVentures director Jason Rathje offers substantial information and evaluation in regards to the early success.

The Materiel Innovation Pipeline rests on a foundational key idea: 20,000 resolution suppliers are higher than 20. According to this examine by Georgetown’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology, the materiel enterprise is dominated by roughly 20 to 25 trade majors, and inside that membership 5 firms e-book practically as a lot income as the remainder of the trade mixed. To break this stranglehold, America wants new pathways for hundreds or tens of hundreds of firms to enter the expertise funnel annually.

The Department of Defense awarded practically 2,000 SBIR awards in Fiscal Year 2019 towards practically 10,000 submissions. Simple logic and my private expertise working with a whole lot of expertise startups dictates that some firms thought of making use of and declined, whereas many others who would have been an incredible technical match by no means even thought of SBIR. So how does the Department of Defense get these 10,000 or 20,000 new entrants to interact, check the waters, and qualify themselves as able to becoming a member of the National Security Innovation Base? There are two essential steps: funnel fill and use-case growth and validation.

Step 1: Funnel Fill

Admit it — protection innovation is enjoyable! T-shirts and hoodies at work, Star Wars-inspired organizational buildings, kombucha (and beer) on faucet, tacos for each meal, cool socks, and all of the robots! Okay, so that you’ve heard the panel on “going faster” and “Other Transaction Agreements” a number of dozen occasions, and sure — it’s repetitive. Boring possibly. But that session isn’t for you. It’s for the hundreds of first-time entrants attracted by the promise of non-dilutive capital.

For those that are unfamiliar, the protection innovation ecosystem is the gathering of organizations and those who join U.S. army stakeholders, startup expertise, and sources to ship revolutionary options that create mission impression for warfighters on the velocity of relevance. Scores of cells signify each conceivable company — too many and too ever-changing to depend or listing, however MITRE’s Acquisition within the Digital Age website maintains a fairly complete and present reference listing. Though their particular person enterprise fashions differ, every entity is organized in the direction of the identical seven aims: to draw non-traditional firms (startups) to the protection market; to make the army group’s issues extra open, accessible, and collaborative; to make proposals and submissions shorter, less complicated, and simpler; to get from solicitation to contract sooner and velocity cost; to make mental property phrases extra versatile; to allow extra and higher buyer interactions and iterations; and eventually to facilitate transition to a fielded system that creates mission impression for warfighters.

They have commonalities: situated in startup hubs, utilizing non-standard software program instruments equivalent to G-Suite, no uniforms in sight, and always showing on panels and internet hosting webinars. As members of the Army Application Laboratory defined in a current “Ask Me Anything” occasion throughout Capital Factory’s Fed Supernova, they’re not attempting to interact firms with GovWin accounts: “we publish about what we do on LinkedIn very extensively, on Twitter extensively, and make sure that we are speaking to our marketplace. Our marketplace is not the primes … it’s the people who know how to use Twitter.”

The authorities faction of the protection innovation ecosystem is dwarfed by the scores of non-government individuals, personalities, and organizations: for-profit, non-profit, public-private partnership, and partnership middleman agreements. They are available in each authorized designation, and so they host occasions, academies, and accelerators. There are even protection innovation “influencers” on numerous social media platforms amplifying content material and alternatives, attracting much more startups.

While some could chide it as irrelevant innovation theater, funnel-fill actions obtain three key aims: entice rising expertise startups who’ve by no means labored with the Department of Defense in a significant manner earlier than; give them sufficient details about army issues, expertise priorities, and gateway standards to make an preliminary dedication whether or not to pursue additional; and introduce startups to sources that may assist them submit their first vital proposal. Most considerably from the division’s perspective, nearly all of funnel-fill actions are carried out by the non-government facet of the protection innovation ecosystem at no direct price to the federal government.

Step 2: Use-Case Development and Validation

Having made the choice to discover dual-use, the subsequent step for a startup is to develop a use-case. Very hardly ever will a startup’s industrial expertise or product instantly translate to a U.S. army buyer with no configuration or integration. In explicit, applied sciences that ship functionality in a multi-domain operations context require domain-specific understanding, together with the working and expertise surroundings the place the answer will probably be deployed, and the dependencies and required integrations.

To have an affordable probability of producing mission impression for warfighters, a use-case wants to deal with 4 questions. What downside does the expertise resolve for a army buyer, or what mission-related functionality does it present? What worth does it create for what person(s) in what contexts? What information, provides, commodities (e.g. gasoline), and many others. does the answer require to operate? What {hardware} or software program programs should it combine with for the person to work together with the answer?

In my interactions with a whole lot of entities throughout the protection innovation ecosystem — startups, buyers, program representatives, and enablers — I hardly ever hear individuals talking about use-cases at this degree of element. Further, irrespective of what number of webinars AFWERX or the Army Applications Laboratory hosts, they’ll by no means scale the required degree of granularity throughout the total vary of issues that they intend to unravel. This is unlucky, as a result of the failure to grasp and account for operational elements throughout product design and growth prevents startups (and their clients) from constructing an answer that integrates. Frequently the trouble leads to a product that demos nicely however solves nothing.

Wasn’t This Supposed to be About Phase-1 SBIRs?

The second step was technically referred to as “use-case development and validation,” however a use-case can’t be “validated” with out buyer and person suggestions, irrespective of how current your area consultants’ experiences and contacts are. It needs to be inferred that the extent of element required to totally develop a use-case consists of some quantity of buyer discovery, engagement, and suggestions. The “product,” now in a wireframed state, would have integrated this suggestions and overcome feasibility objections.

SBIR jargon calls this course of “feasibility study.” In the phase-1 proposal an organization describes conceptually how their expertise and analysis strategy can accomplish the analysis and growth aims. During phase-1 efficiency, they validate that idea and additional develop and refine it right into a plan. In follow, the phase-1 efficiency spans the very finish of step 1 (qualifying the expertise) and all of step 2. The finest phase-2 proposals incorporate their discovery referring to the 4 use-case questions and element a expertise strategy to construct an answer that not solely solves the issue, however may combine and scale. Ergo, ship mission impression.

The phase-1 presents an accessible and funded pathway to develop and validate the use-case. And as a result of it’s accessible and funded, notably when packaged with streamlined submissions and contracting, tons and plenty of firms can do it. And tons and plenty of firms are doing it — the excessive quantity of phase-1 submissions is the objective, not a flaw within the system. What occurs if the startup fails to validate their use-case, finds that the shopper doesn’t actually care about their proposed function of operate, or learns that the answer would by no means combine? Kill the mission at phase-1. Fail quick.

Let’s evaluate that to the foreseeable end result if there isn’t a phase-1 choice and corporations are required to go straight to phase-2. Proposals for the second section are far more detailed and troublesome to put in writing, making them much less accessible. This means fewer new entrants. Startups would nonetheless be required to interact stakeholders and customers to validate and flesh out their use-case, however with out funding or a contracted relationship to facilitate entry. Fewer certified use-cases. The firms most geared up to submit a really detailed technical strategy are these particularly organized for enterprise with the Department of Defense. This would imply extra SBIR mills. Customers should wait two years for the primary alternative to pivot or offload initiatives that aren’t working. Fail gradual.

With deeper evaluation, this smells rather a lot just like the outdated manner. To ship steady innovation on the velocity of relevance, the Department of Defense wants a brand new manner. The excellent news is that there are early indications that it’s working!

Building a real nationwide safety innovation base requires hundreds or tens of hundreds of latest firms and options to enter the funnel annually. Phase-1 allows and attracts new entrants. Those firms have to be certified as a match — each the corporate and the expertise — to develop and ship a functionality that’s related to multi-domain operations. Phase-1 allows firms to discover a expertise match. Once certified, the corporate must develop an in depth use-case that accounts not just for a lab-based resolution, but in addition for one that might deploy to the person base and combine with their current programs and workflows. Phase-1 leads to higher phase-2s.

Phase-1 SBIRs are a helpful filtering instrument and guarantee most participation from dual-use startups. Use them properly quite than discard them.



Kevin Landtroop is a former cavalry officer and legal professional within the U.S. Army and at the moment develops methods for expertise startups to develop use-cases and ship cutting-edge options to the nationwide safety group. Kevin based the Texas Defense Innovation Forum, served as vp and the inaugural director of the Center for Defense Innovation on the Capital Factory in Austin, Texas, and teaches Hacking for Defense on the University of Texas. Kevin at the moment works with a portfolio of over 100 dual-use firms serving to them to beat program and contracting challenges to ship mission impression to warfighters.

Image: AFWERX Public Affairs